| Posted on March 26th, 2008 |
|
that’s almost how long ago it was that i watched this. i remember i thought it took a while to get its footing - some of the ‘dormitory life’ blocking seemed a bit forced, and the first shakey handheld as we follow otilia to the bus felt a bit out of place. but i really appreciated the payoffs on both of these. the handheld bit set up the tense creepy walk at the end (and after that scene when they finally have a small cut in time - whew, what a relief that was.) but most compelling for me were that all the relationships i thought reached the level of realism they attempt in the opening scene. otilia and her boyfriend - especially during the dinner party when he’s whining in his room. the abortionist and both the girls - how they each have a different level of trying to keep the relationship normal. gabita with her cakes, otilia with her nervous attempt at a conversation (’i was afraid we would miss each other…’) and the abortionist with how he treads the line of helping them but still letting them know he has zero sympathy. the centerpiece seemed to be otilia and gabita, and much of the point seems to be to slam gabita for her weakness and how she uses her weakness to get her way. so i found that particular relationship annoying in its purposefulness but it was so well-observed and sharply drawn i still appreciated it. i also really liked marinca as otilia. something about her expressions and rushed casualness really helped the feel.
i did think it was a bit too much to have otilia agree to the abortionist’s demand. maybe it was realistic for that time/place and what needed to happen, but it felt unnecessary to the narrative. yes, otilia had her own concerns in mind, but she was already going to ridiculous lengths to help gabita. and tension and weight-wise i thought things were pretty tight and heavy as they were. when otilia finds the knife that was enough for me.
gabita’s dinner was also pretty awesome.
Similar Reviews | No Comments »